I just watched my greyhound, Sache, chew at her itchy spots so vigorously that, once satisfied, her head was lowered to the sofa with a “thud”: She had worn herself out scratching at what itched her. After an afternoon of hunting for answers, I get the feeling that I have done the same.
Up until a few minutes ago, this post had contained a second rant against the Washington DC Catholic Archdiocese and their decision to strike out against the helpless in order to make heard their tantrum against those pesky, evil homosexuals. It was accompanied by a graphic showing my conversation with a Tweeting nun who is vocal in her support of their bigotry. While I am leaving a link to that image, I am replacing the rant. I do so not because I think any differently, nor because I am any less desirous of a real answer to my questions, but because there was, in the first iteration of this post, far too much essence of the little girl who was ever frustrated to the point of seething over the priests’, nuns’ and CCD teachers’ inability to answer any of her more difficult — but infinitely and importantly meaningful — questions about the faith they wanted her to adopt. Her frustration had been born in large part out of fear that not believing all things Catholic would disappoint the adults who so wished her to be a good and pious girl.
I do not need that little girl to speak for me any more. I no longer look for answers to the questions she asked, as I am certain that no one has them. No priest or nun can convince me that their institutionalized bigotry and sexism can bring me to a better relationship with god. Religion, I have come to understand, is - at best - a tool used to measure, and to better, oneself. Washington DC’s Archdiocese leaders, and thru her endorsement of their actions, Sister Anne, all serve as a perfect example of how religion ought not be — but too often is — used: as a thick, barbed yardstick used first to measure and then to inflict punishment upon others. If the Catholic Archdiocese of Washington DC wants to penalize the needy in their community, as well as their own parish members, over a law made outside of their organization, then let them have their tantrum. In the end, this whole thing will empty their pews and further define their hypocrisy in the eyes of those who had perhaps wavered in their opinions. Sister Anne’s and the Archdiocese’s pathetic attempts to cite legal (read: state-granted) “religious freedom” as a reason or an excuse for their actions simply skirts the real issue here: They are beating their own family for the sins of the neighbor. Inexcusable.
Sister Anne, you are no more equipped to give me a straight answer regarding the non-legal, the ethical/moral aspect of the Archdiocese’s actions than were the nuns of my childhood. Faith is not enough. A calling and its implied special unity with the godhead is not enough. A simple, honest answer would be enough, but none of you are capable. Since I no longer desire the run-around, the excuses and vague platitudes, I beg you: don’t even try. You might strain something.